Is SuperTech Synthetic Oil as good as Red Line? Let's find out!

Loading...
  • Published on: 18 March 2019
  • Why spend $11.95 for a quart of Red Line synthetic motor oil when you can buy a quart of full synthetic Walmart SuperTech for less than half that price? Is Walmart SuperTech as good as Red Line? Let's find out! I purchased both of these products using my own money. I am not sponsored by Walmart or Red Line or by any product manufacturer. 100% of Project Farm videos are ideas that come from those leaving comments. So, thank you very much for requesting this video! In the previous episodes, Amsoil won over Royal Purple and will advance to next round in the oil championship series.

    The testing methods outlined in this video are my own and not performed using expensive oil lab testing equipment or following the ASTM, SAE or API testing standards. The three tests outlined in the video include tests for viscosity at varying temperatures, film strength, and evaporative testing. In my opinion, the testing approaches used in this video provide consumers with valuable information on choosing the right motor oil for their specific application. Hope you enjoy the rest of the video and thank you very much for supporting the channel by watching the commercials and through Patreon support. https://www.patreon.com/projectfarm

    This video is only for entertainment purposes. If you rely on the information portrayed in this video, you assume the responsibility for the results. Project Farm LLC
  • Runtime : 10:10
  • Seafoam oil sea foam lucas marvel mystery oil marvels marvel mystery oil seefoam Sea foam Seefoam See Foam does seafoam work wd-40 project farm amazon basics oil mobil 1 synthetic oil walmart supertech super tech oil oil playoff oil showdown oil series synthetic motor oil test synthetic motor oil comparison synthetic motor oil vs conventional motor oil competition red line redline redline synthetic oil ester base stock ester red line

COMMENTS: 40

  • eldridge201
    eldridge201   7 hours ago

    Why did you say that Red Line won this contest? SUPER TECH beat it in every test with the exception of the "cooking" test and even that was really too close to make a difference. The "film strength" test where you chose Redline over Super Tech was wrong (in my opinion) and you can visually see it if you look at the pieces of metal in the video after each test. You can see in the visual test that the Super Tech actually looked like better (less) wear and it didn't lose any more weight than Redline in the friction test. The temperature was worse for Super Tech but it was pretty close. The wattage test was better for Super Tech. I understand that your length and width measurements show otherwise but it is so close that I would argue that you may have measured incorrectly. Even thoughnit looks like Super Tech has a slightly longer pattern, I don't think it looks wider than Redline. It appears that the Redline actually has a wider wear pattern. Also, it "appears" (just by lookkng at the still frame at 4:37) that Super Tech has a "smoother" appearance which would indicate less friction (in my opinion) therefore the wear would be less. SUPER TECH clearly won the speed tests with new and "burned" oil. Even the cooking test was super close and not really different enough to make it worth considering either one a winner or loser. I'm confused about how you chose Redline to beat Super Tech and said "obviously" Redline won. No, it wasn't "obvious" at all. Even in your video we can see the evidence that Super Tech won. I think you should watch your own video again and change the results. SUPER TECH actually won this comparison. Or, do the comparison on more time. This one doesn't seem to have the correct winner.

  • J.T. Cooper
    J.T. Cooper   20 hours ago

    I love all of the money I've saved over 20 years of using Super Tech Full Synthetic in all of my vehicles. No oil related problems in over 20 years now. I am still waiting to see the comparison of Amazon and Super Tech. I'll bet it's the same.

  • Afiq Osman
    Afiq Osman   2 days ago

    Nice video. Suprising result. Can you do Supertech vs Mag1. Both from warren. Mag1 is their premium product.

  • ZEEKUPP
    ZEEKUPP   2 days ago

    Nice vid. That was a well ran test.

  • Sean Smock
    Sean Smock   4 days ago

    Honda guys are gonna hate this one! Most of them swear by redline:)

  • Nick Bermel
    Nick Bermel   5 days ago

    Wow!!! Unbelievable!! I might be using super tech from now on!!

  • John Markz
    John Markz   5 days ago

    Do you have test about oil mixed with coolant? Vs oil mixed with water?

  • Chance Neel
    Chance Neel   5 days ago

    Should add a wear test after the evaporation loss test :)

  • clockhanded
    clockhanded   5 days ago

    I have a 2010 XB with a 160k mile 2AZFE engine. These engines are notorious for burning oil. What oil would you guys advise?

  • mopar 2ya
    mopar 2ya   6 days ago

    Nice comparison. For a daily driver I wouldnt hesitate to run the supertech for a second. I tried it in a manual trans from 1991 that called for 5-30 conventional and it reduced friction to the point the brass stop rings wouldnt function properly if shifting somewhat quick. I switch to Redline MTL synthetic and works good again.

  • BRYAN351
    BRYAN351   1 weeks ago

    VIDEO IDEA ~ My brother is a manager at a large auto auction, and he talked to some auto engineers one time who said they conducted tests comparing conventional and synthetic oils, and that 4 qts. of conv. + 1 qt. of syn. mixed together performed AS WELL as 5 qts. of syn. I would love to know if that's true.

  • Tevo77777
    Tevo77777   1 weeks ago

    Kinda sad that said video hasn't come out yet.

  • Midwest Corvette
    Midwest Corvette   1 weeks ago

    Always used pennzoil ultra platinum and switched to super tech because I was feeling cheap on the oil change. One thing I noticed is my cars oil temp runs hotter. Normally pennzoil 198ish and with super tech it’s like 210-212.

  • john
    john   1 weeks ago

    Have been using super tech for a few years now. A good quality oil for reasonable price. Recently, I found Costco also has an oil which beats Walmart’s price!

  • Charissa
    Charissa   1 weeks ago

    Supertech vs amazon basics all the way

  • Justin_DC4
    Justin_DC4   1 weeks ago

    I would like to see stp oil go against car quest oil

  • Hotrod 289
    Hotrod 289   1 weeks ago

    Please do a short vid comparing your results on Super tech vs shell oil (red bottle for gas engines)and amazon basics.😁

  • Alex
    Alex   1 weeks ago

    Talk about militec1

  • P47 Thunderbolt
    P47 Thunderbolt   2 weeks ago

    I think MAG 1 oil is made by same company not sure it's same formula . Notice MAG 1 has been getting some notoriety and just wondering .A gallon jug of MAG 1 is $51 at Wal-Mart online . States its from Warren Distribution .

  • P47 Thunderbolt
    P47 Thunderbolt   2 weeks ago

    Would there be anyway to test Castrol Magnatec and it's claims of clinging to metal parts for less wear on cold starts ?

  • P47 Thunderbolt
    P47 Thunderbolt   2 weeks ago

    Have you done the Havoline ProDS oils ?Quaker State Ultimate ? Like to see both in 0w20 Also like to see some of the 0w16 oils . Sister just bought a new Toyota and it calls for a 0W16 didn't realize there was such a thing . Thanks for everything.

  • Lloyd Flores
    Lloyd Flores   2 weeks ago

    Can you do one on Kirkland synthetic oil?

  • HotRod Ray
    HotRod Ray   2 weeks ago

    If you keep a car 60,000 miles the extra $400 you spend on fancy $$ oil only helps the next owner.All you've done is lose money.Too pragmatic and analytical ??

  • HotRod Ray
    HotRod Ray   2 weeks ago

    I always wonder how much gunk gets on the valves from the evaporated oil.No way of determining that.I wonder how good SeaFoam is cleaning those gunky valves.

  • 1212goose
    1212goose   2 weeks ago

    Anyway i can talk you into doing motorcycle oil? It has a clutch additive comes in syn or conventional. You can find all the brands you did in you big bracket plus yamalube, repsol oil, Kawasaki oil and a few others.

  • Scotty doesn'tKNOW
    Scotty doesn'tKNOW   2 weeks ago

    In my opinion the super tech wins due to the minor differences in products but the huge cost difference

  • Frank Salem
    Frank Salem   2 weeks ago

    I use to test my oils in the sixties , for example I poured in a baby moon hub caps a cup of Pennzoil 30w and in the other hub cap I put Texico Havoline 30w, then heated them on a outdoor stove on the top (not in oven) for 20 min , well to my surprise Tex Havoline kept its consistent grade and the Penzoil got thick and gummy ( not good for lifters and bearings),(do not try this indoors, house, garage etc.)

  • ThePattycake1313
    ThePattycake1313   2 weeks ago

    can KY be used in a car? And can supertech be used as a lube?

  • william foreman
    william foreman   2 weeks ago

    Is there anyway you could ever do a test on five or six different popular oil filters including Walmart super tech that would actually show them being used somehow and then show us which one is actually doing what they say they can do and which ones aren’t,,,anybody can cut them open and those cut open reviews are great however is there a way to really test one’s efficiency?

  • Donald Duck
    Donald Duck   2 weeks ago

    Wich one is better: redline or penrite?

  • The Expert
    The Expert   2 weeks ago

    You have a PHD in automotive technology

  • MrPowecat
    MrPowecat   2 weeks ago

    Have you ever tested Ultra Lube oil???

  • Greg Stine
    Greg Stine   2 weeks ago

    I use Royale Purple in my vehicles, my Chevy Colorado with 200,000 miles on it no issues but I agree, regular vehicles maintenance is the key no matter what oil you use.

  • Rubens 1LE
    Rubens 1LE   3 weeks ago

    Totally changed how I feel about Super Tech, well done!

  • John Waid
    John Waid   3 weeks ago

    I’ve heard more and more people using this super tec oil and having good luck with it! Seems funny it’s the same oil as the high dollar brands I think so.. Thanks again for your time and work I’m doing these awesome videos “”Project Farm”

  • Matt Stuart
    Matt Stuart   3 weeks ago

    Hey do you think you could compare some different rear end oil brands I know supertect makes 1 and I like to see if its just as good as other brands thank you.

  • Esteban Mederes
    Esteban Mederes   3 weeks ago

    I would appreciate to see the comparison between Syn3 from Harley Davidson and Mobil1 or any heavyweight competitor in the market like Amsoil, Redlineor even Motul. I see a lot of tabu around those HD products. Personally, I think HD oil is an overpriced crap, you would help a lot to the biker community. Hope this commentary get enough support and thumbs up to be materialized by you. Great channel by the way.